State Sen. Colbeck: Thoughts on Truth and Proposal 2

With an election on the horizon, Sen. Colbeck reflects on the principle of truth.

The following is a column submitted by State Sen. Patrick Colbeck (R-Canton).

In a world full of access to more information than ever before, it is remarkable that the information we most need is often the hardest to find – the truth. 

The truth was very important to our Founding Fathers:

“We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness…”

Why is the truth hard to find today? 

Perhaps it is apathy. There are many other pleasures in life to pursue. Why spend precious time dwelling on the search for the truth regarding the issues of the day?

Perhaps it is simply the volume of information. Most of us are inundated with information from email, websites, TV and newspapers.

Perhaps it is confusion. In our 30-second sound bite world, critical thinking often succumbs to impulsive thinking as people adopt the “truth” that is pushed to them in the most frequent, entertaining and engaging manner. 

Many “truth” organizations have popped up to take advantage of our desire for the truth. One thing I know for sure is that the more we abdicate our jobs as responsible citizens, the more we grow in dependence upon those who would seek to use this dependence for their own gains. Many organizations are more than willing to fill that job for us. Many of these organizations do not have truth as their primary objective.

Nowhere is the need for truth more evident than in proposed changes to the Michigan Constitution this November. Each of us will be bombarded by media ads marketing one side of the issue or another, but did you know that the marketing has also found its way onto your ballot? 

You see, the wording of each proposal to amend the constitution only shows a “summary” of the proposed amendment. These summaries are generally filled with marketing platitudes, since the full text of the amendments does not typically fit within the 100 word constraint of the ballot. The actual wording of each amendment as it would appear in our constitution can be found in the original ballot petitions filed with the State Board of Canvassers. These petitions can be found on the State Board of Canvassers web page, which is located in an obscure corner of the secretary of state website (www.michigan.gov/sos) under “Elections in Michigan.” 

Our governor and attorney general attempted to protect the Michigan Constitution when they filed court papers challenging Proposal 2 on the basis that the truth of its impacts could not be summarized in 100 words or less. These potential impacts are significant and would likely include a $1.6B tax increase that would push jobs out of our state not “protect” them. In my opinion, Governor Snyder and Attorney General Schuette were correct to raise concerns over Proposal 2. 

You can decide for yourself, however, by reviewing the actual petitions and comparing them to the 100 words or less ballot wording.  You now have a choice to make as a citizen. Will you take the advice of the former Speaker of the House Nancy Pelosi and “pass the bill” before you see what's inside, or will you “READ THE BILL” before casting your vote?

The key to consistently understanding the truth is to go to the source materials. When I vote in the Senate, I make my voting decisions on the basis of the actual bill, not the summaries from legislative analysts. Legislative summaries provided by analysts are nice to have as reference, but the summaries are not what get put into law. Such is the case with the proposal language that will appear on our ballots this November. The summaries are not what are put into law. The original petition wording is what goes into law if the proposal is passed.

There is no substitute for source documents, source videos or source statements. When people are simply talking about information sources rather than pointing you to the source, it should raise concerns as to whether or not their assertions are true. It may take you more time to find and review the source information, but you will sleep much better with your decision.

Sadly, the truth is often controversial. I know that I may be ridiculed and attacked for the simple act of exhorting my fellow citizens to pursue the truth. I take solace, however, from the following words of wisdom from Mahatma Gandhi:

“First they ignore you, then they ridicule you, then they fight you, then you win.” –Mahatma Gandhi.

When the truth wins, we all win. After all, it is truth that sets us all free.

Sheryl Edwards September 19, 2012 at 06:03 PM
I happen to agree with Sen. Colbeck: you SHOULD read the proposals, all of them, unlike that ridiculous ad that has the two people sitting at a table and saying "just say no" to all of them. They are very different proposals that should be read. And I am one who happens to be supporting Prop. 2, but it is apathy and ignorance to ignore what each of the proposals say.
Denise Nash September 19, 2012 at 06:51 PM
I agree with Mark and Sheryl that the Truth is something we should all embrace. I agree with Mr. Colbeck, that sometimes it is hard to find the truth. The political machine has a tendency to slant it towards their goals. They repeat and repeat lies which eventually (they think) are accepted as truth. I also support Proposal 2. Interesting that Mr. Colbeck quoted Gandhi. “First they ignore you, then they ridicule you, then they fight you, then you win.” This is something that the Occupy Movement and the 99% have been counting on. They are in the fight stage now, and I hope they are successful.
Jerry Hilliard September 19, 2012 at 07:05 PM
The idea is admirable, but it is not that hard to find the complete proposal. Who goes to the state web site to find anything, it is a mess. A simple search engine search can find what you need in a small amount of time. Also I would like to know the bill number(s) of the tax increases that he thinks will be passed in the republican controled legislature? Where does the $1.6 billion tax increase come from, if he is speaking of increases in taxes from the current laws, that would mean that the economy would have to be doing better and that increase would come directly in the form of higher wages paid to workers, who would then spend the money, which, by the way is exactly what the economy needs right now. That may be bad from Colbeck's point of view but would not change the ROI for the companies doing business in this state, unless ROI went up do to economies of scale. It would be idiotic for companies to leave Michigan with all that new income people would have to spend. Indeed we should be informed, but not by reading propaganda such as this "letter to the editor".
Patti McCoin September 19, 2012 at 11:25 PM
Since this letter to the editor was all about finding the original source of information I would also be interested in the source of the 1.6 billion dollar tax increase. I'm sure that as a legislator so firmly committed to the truth it was an oversight not to include a link to the original document.
Sam Galate September 20, 2012 at 01:13 AM
I think this is the source of the senator's information. http://www.michigancapitolconfidential.com/17534?fb_comment_id=fbc_403634916357547_3919215_404381872949518# This is the Mackinac Center. Check out their funding and reputation in the link below. They're shills for Koch, DeVos, energy, business, etc. Their "research" is questionable, at best. If you're looking for truth, this isn't the place. http://www.rightwingwatch.org/content/mackinac-center-public-policy Senator, when I asked you how you could pass SB1040 (and 500+ other bills) with immediate effect, you deleted all of my comments and blocked me from posting on your Facebook page. So what is the truth on this issue? Remember, the truth shall set you free. What would Gandhi do?


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »