Michigan’s ‘Rape Insurance’ Law Limiting Abortion Coverage Takes Effect

Supporters admit law won't cause a decline in abortions; opponents call it "a direct attack on women" that could have unintended consequences that cost women tens of thousands of dollars for medically necessary procedures.

The Abortion Insurance Opt-Out Law, passed by the Republican-controlled Michigan Legislature last year, means that women who haven't purchased insurance riders won't be covered for abortion services.
The Abortion Insurance Opt-Out Law, passed by the Republican-controlled Michigan Legislature last year, means that women who haven't purchased insurance riders won't be covered for abortion services.

A law requiring Michigan women to purchase a rider if they expect their private health insurance to cover abortion services takes effect Thursday.

Right to Life Michigan admits the Abortion Insurance Opt-Out Act won’t  lower abortion rates in the state, but will shift the burden on who pays for the services. Opponents say it’s a draconian law that threatens women’s health by limiting their access to a procedure that is legal and constitutionally protected, the Detroit Free Press reports.

The law applies even when an unwanted pregnancy is a result of rape or incest – a circumstance that prompted an impassioned plea by State Sen. Gretchen Whitmer (D-East Lansing) last winter, when she disclosed last January that she had been raped 20 years ago.

Pregnancy didn’t result, but she said she “can’t even begin to imagine now having to think about the same thing happening to my own daughters" in Michigan's anti-abortion climate.

Whitmer and others tried unsuccessfully to get the bill repealed. Failing that, they urged voters to remember lawmakers who voted for it at the polls.

When the law takes effect Thursday, women who had not purchased the add-on riders ahead of time won’t be reimbursed if they have an abortion. 

That's a moot point, as no insurance companies will be offering those riders to new customers in the private marketplace after the law takes effect, the state’s Department of Insurance and Financial Services spokesman Caleb Buhs told the Free Press.

Insurers had to tell the state in February if they planned to offer and sell abortion coverage. Seven said they would, but only as part of of employer-sponsored plans. As a result, anyone who purchases insurance as an individual, whether on the private health insurance marketplace or the new federal health-care exchange under the Affordable Care Act, won’t be able to obtain coverage for abortion services.

Elective Abortions Already Declining in Michigan

The Abortion Insurance Opt-Out Act was passed in December by Michigan’s Republican-controlled legislature after stormy debate.

Democrats called it the “rape insurance bill” because it require women to buy coverage they may not anticipate needing. Whitmer told the Free Press that it could limit coverage for a medically necessary D&C procedure, meaning the woman would have to bear on her own the cost of a procedure that could costs tens of thousands of dollars.

The majority of abortions in Michigan – and nationwide – are already paid out-of-pocket, the newspaper said. Department of Community Health statistics show that only 3 percent of the 22,700 abortions performed in Michigan in 2012 were covered by insurance. Abortions have also plummeted 52 percent from 1987-2012, the statistics show.

“This isn’t talking about someone looking for an elective abortion,” Whitmer said. “This is a woman with a wanted pregnancy who is forced to terminate it because of health concerns and may now may face financial ruin for doing nothing more than trying to start a family.

“If that’s not a direct attack on women and our health to say insurance can’t cover this type of critically important reproductive care, I don’t know what is,” she said.

Right to Life Michigan spokeswoman Genevieve Marnon defended the legislation.

“Do we anticipate this will lower abortion rates? No,” she said.. “But ... it’s one thing for you to pay for your abortion and another thing for me to have to pay for it.”

Luther's Fan March 22, 2014 at 03:11 PM
Mcgurk Why are you folks always so angry. You call Christians the intolerant haters yet listen to yourself. You name call and say all kinds of cynical things against our beliefs. At least we stand on something and are willing to take the heat for it. I have no problem with all people exercising 1st Amendment rights, but apparently you do.
McGurk March 22, 2014 at 03:23 PM
LF: I am but a minority of one. Thus, you confuse me by using terms like, "you folks". Please understand, your beliefs are fine. I could care less. The anger you perceive from me is not meant to be collective. It is specific. Towards Dale and you. It is not your beliefs and those with whom you think share them that is the basis of my commentary. It is your specific, individual and misguided commentary. To me, Dale and you are not christians. You two, bend the bible to fit your warped view of the world. And in that, you find comfort in chastising those who are different. My commentary is only in response or reply. My humility prevents me from preaching in the affirmative.
madelefant@gmail.com March 25, 2014 at 05:25 PM
It is interesting when people infuse religion with political legislation. Jesus was clear about that issue. Separation of Church and state was his proclamation. "Render unto Caesar those thing's that are Caesars, and unto God, those thing's that are God's." When you mix your religion with the state you become complicit in the crimes of the state and thus you take God's name in vain.
Dale Murrish March 25, 2014 at 05:48 PM
That's a twisting of Scripture I've never heard before. "Render unto Caesar those thing's that are Caesars, and unto God, those thing's that are God's" means that government has its sphere and the church has its sphere. The church can and should have input on moral issues. Do you object when churches get involved in social causes you agree with?
Luther's Fan March 25, 2014 at 06:09 PM
Good point Dale. Many laws involving encroachment are based on the commandments. Thou shalt not kill, steal, commit adultery... still have their place in the civil and moral realm.


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »